A Pragmatic Legal Expert System

James Popple

Applied Legal Philosophy Series, Dartmouth (Ashgate), Aldershot, May 1996, xviii + 384 pp., ISBN 1 85521 739 2.

Most legal expert systems attempt to implement complex models of legal reasoning. This book argues that a complex model is unnecessary. It advocates a simpler, pragmatic approach in which the utility of a legal expert system is evaluated by reference, not to the extent to which it simulates a lawyer's approach to a legal problem, but to the quality of its predictions and of its arguments. The author describes the development of a legal expert system, called SHYSTER, which takes a pragmatic approach to case law. He discusses the testing of SHYSTER in four different and disparate areas of case law, and draws conclusions about the advantages and limitations of this approach to legal expert system development.

Chapter 1 presents a critical analysis of previous work of relevance to the development of legal expert systems. Chapter 2 explains the pragmatic approach that was adopted in the development of SHYSTER. The implementation of SHYSTER is detailed using examples in chapter 3. Chapter 4 describes the testing of SHYSTER, and conclusions are drawn from those tests in chapter 5. Examples of SHYSTER's output are provided in appendices.

The book is out of print, but it can be downloaded for no charge as a PDF file (8.6M/406 pages). An abstract, full bibliographical details, and the example output given in the appendices are also available.

If you download the book, and would like to make a donation to the author, you can do so (using PayPal) by clicking on the button to the right.
The book is included in Google Books and the Internet Archive.   Google Books Internet Archive
PDF PDF files can be read and printed using Adobe's free Reader.   Get Adobe Reader

Copyright noticeValid HTML 4.0
Home page:  <>
E-mail:  <>
Last modified:  21 May 1996